2005Forum Cameras (Film/Video/HD)
Comparaison du Movietube avec les adaptateurs cinéma numérique PS Techniks Mini35 et Pro35
Il y a 21 ans. Le matériel et les prix ont peut-être changé depuis.
Ce que le fil a révélé
- Le Movietube utilise une caméra inversée avec un écran de film microcristallin au lieu de la rotation du verre de fond, potentiellement nécessitant moins de puissance et offrant une meilleure transmission de lumière que les solutions de rotation du verre.
- The Movietube balances well on cinema arms when properly rigged with appropriate counterweights, performing at the lightest spring setting.
- Image quality from the Movietube is comparable to PS Techniks units, with finer and more static grain that is easier to remove in post-production than grain from rotating ground glass.
- The Movietube has a tighter and more responsive balance mechanism compared to PS Techniks, behaving more like a film camera for handheld operation.
- Build quality and operational versatility of the Movietube are considered superior to some PS Techniks configurations, though the increased camera height can be problematic for certain shots.
- The Movietube is priced lower than the Mini35 while offering features like a prism to keep the camera upright, making it suitable for professional client work.
- Cheap cinema adapters using ground CDs as gates are not comparable in quality to the Movietube or PS Techniks and are unsuitable for professional work.
- The tall profile of the Movietube can provide a higher center of gravity, which may improve gimbal performance when used with lighter cinema arms without significantly adding weight.
Dépend de
- The Movietube is only compatible with miniDV or HDV cameras.
- Participants had limited hands-on experience at the time of discussion; the Movietube was relatively new to market.
- No definitive data on power consumption differences between systems was provided.
- The discussion did not resolve comparative costs when renting with additional lens packages versus alternatives like Varicam.