2007Cameras (Film/Video/HD) forum
Comparison of HVX and Sony EX1 cameras for professional video production
19 years old. Gear and prices may have changed since.
What the thread found
- The Sony EX1 demonstrates superior low light performance compared to the HVX, though the exact cause may relate to optics or sensor size differences
- The Sony EX1 produces richer blacks with less noise than the HVX
- The Sony EX1 features a marked iris ring and focus ring with start and stop points, whereas the HVX has unmarked dials that continuously spin
- The Sony EX1 includes a focus peaking function that can be assigned a color to display which elements are in focus through the viewfinder
- The HVX uses P2 card workflow which some users report adds significant time to post-production and requires dedicated staff
- The Sony EX1 provides more onboard storage capacity on memory cards, reducing production interruptions during data transfer
- The Sony EX1 requires a downconverter to output standard definition video
- Reports suggest potential lens issues on the Sony EX1 between 10mm and 20mm focal lengths at certain aperture settings, though details were unclear
- The HVX offers variable speed and shutter controls appreciated by some users
- Alternative cameras mentioned include the Canon XLH1 with 24-frame mode for a more film-like appearance, and JVC models in the GY-HD series
Depends on
- The Sony EX1 user had only 10 days of experience with that camera
- The lens issue report on the Sony EX1 was secondhand information
- Only one user specifically mentioned shooting a full production with the HVX
- Different users prioritized different features, making direct comparison dependent on individual workflow needs
- Discussion occurred in 2007, so camera capabilities and market conditions have changed