2005Off Topic forum
Canon HDV camera specifications and design comparison with competitors
21 years old. Gear and prices may have changed since.
DisputedParticipants disagreed and reached no conclusion. Read the findings as positions, not as an answer.
What the thread found
- The camera shoots HDV at MPEG2 25mbps to tape with 1080i resolution and supports 60i, 30f, and 24f frame rates.
- The camera includes professional studio connections such as HD-SDI output, Genlock input, and timecode in and out.
- It can record in both HD and SD formats, with DV to tape and SD-SDI output capabilities.
- The camera supports computer control via firewire with special software for full parameter adjustment.
- An optional upgrade allows format switching between 60i and 50i for NTSC and PAL standards.
- The design maintains the same form factor as the XL2 model, which some users found limiting for accessories and shoulder mounting.
- Compared to competitor models like the JVC HD100, the Canon design places controls less intuitively and makes the camera front-heavy for handheld operation.
- The 24f mode works around HDV standard limitations by flagging frames and reconstructing them on output to simulate 24p recording.
Depends on
- The chips are interlaced only despite supporting frame-based recording modes.
- Only one lens was available at release, though Mini35 lenses could be adapted.
- The design inherited limitations from previous XL models that created ergonomic challenges with easily-knocked physical controls.
- The professional features like HD-SDI are primarily useful for studio work, limiting their value for field production with smaller sensors.
- Reports on the 24f implementation quality were preliminary at the time of discussion.