SteadiHub
2010Operating forum

HDMI to SDI/HD-SDI conversion for Canon 5D Mark II video output during recording

16 years old. Gear and prices may have changed since.

DisputedParticipants disagreed and reached no conclusion. Read the findings as positions, not as an answer.

What the thread found

  • The Canon 5D Mark II outputs different video formats depending on mode: 1080i at 60fps during preview and playback, but switches to 486i during recording, which causes many HDMI-to-SDI converters to lose signal or experience delays
  • Blackmagic converters work with the 5D Mark II but experience brief signal dropout and delay of several seconds when the camera switches into record mode as the converter relocks to the new signal format
  • AJA HDMI-to-SDI converters have compatibility issues with the 5D Mark II during recording mode
  • The Convergent Design converter may be a viable option for this conversion task
  • Using an HDMI-to-DVI adapter with a Marshall 8.4-inch HD-SDI monitor provides better image quality than composite SD output and eliminates some converter complications
  • The 5D Mark II composite SD output quality is insufficient for reliable focus pulling on a monitor and requires use of camera focus assist features
  • Some operators successfully use the SD composite output with steadicam work without requiring conversion, relying on camera focus assist and framing confirmation rather than precise focus monitoring

Depends on

  • Datavideo converters showed good quality output during 1080i mode but the thread does not confirm their performance during the problematic 486i recording mode
  • The discussion involves mixed experiences and unresolved technical challenges rather than definitive solutions
  • Testing of some proposed converters was promised but results were not reported in the thread
  • The Decimator 2 converter mentioned cannot accept HDMI input and only works in the opposite direction
  • Observations about focus pulling and monitor usability are influenced by individual workflow preferences and may not apply universally
Read the original threadAsk about this threadThe answer cites the archive