SteadiHub
2006Monitors forum

Comparison of LCD and monochrome green CRT monitors for Steadicam operations

20 years old. Gear and prices may have changed since.

DisputedParticipants disagreed and reached no conclusion. Read the findings as positions, not as an answer.

What the thread found

  • Operators who started with LCD monitors tend to prefer them over monochrome green screens, while those experienced with green screens often value their capabilities for exposure metering and low-light work.
  • LCD monitors provide color imaging and can help operators better understand the story being told in a scene, whereas green screens were traditionally used for low-light and night work.
  • Green screen monitors allow more precise exposure control in difficult lighting situations and maintain consistent brightness regardless of viewing angle, while LCD displays change appearance based on viewing angle.
  • LCD monitors have temperature limitations, typically rated only to 32 degrees Fahrenheit, and may experience performance degradation or LCD freezing in below-freezing conditions with extended exposure.
  • Monitor weight affects Steadicam rig balance and can be managed through bracket design or added weight to maintain proper dynamic balance without compromising mobility.
  • Both LCD and green screen solutions have valid applications depending on shooting conditions and operator preference, and modern LCD monitors have addressed many earlier limitations including brightness and viewing angles.

Depends on

  • Discussion from 2006, so monitor technology has evolved significantly since then.
  • Some claims about color versus monochrome perception and storytelling are subjective opinions rather than technical facts.
  • Specific temperature performance data for LCD monitors is anecdotal rather than rigorously tested across all models.
  • The comparison is primarily based on professional camera operator experience with specific monitor models rather than comprehensive technical specifications.
  • Some participants acknowledge earlier posts on the same topic without re-presenting the full arguments.
Read the original threadAsk about this threadThe answer cites the archive